The Emptiness After Success Is Where the Real Questions Begin | Hanni Liang
Backstage Wisdom Podcast • EP 5
Why dogmas, pressure and perfection aren't enough — and how emptiness, risk and connection can open the door to a new kind of artistic freedom
A debut at the Elbphilharmonie, as soloist, playing Franz Liszt's First Piano Concerto. A dream come true — and then the question: now what?
For many classical musicians, the path looks mapped out in advance: practice, competitions, prizes, concerts, an agency. A linear road with the big stage waiting at the end. But what happens when that goal is reached — and instead of fulfillment, an unexpected emptiness shows up?
Hanni Liang knows that moment well. She grew up in a non-musician family, started piano at eight, became a Jungstudentin (a pre-college student at a music academy), and followed a fairly classical path. Today she's a concert pianist, concert designer, a lecturer in Concert Design at the Munich University of Music and Performing Arts — and maybe something like a music activist. She moves deliberately in the tension between tradition and innovation, develops new, interactive concert formats, and occasionally performs works generated entirely by AI.
In conversation with Marco Hohner, we get to the questions that surfaced right after she reached the summit: Why do I actually make music? Who am I playing for? And what do I actually want my music to do in this society?
We talk about dogma and performance pressure in classical music, about the comfort zones musicians build around themselves and how to grow past them, about improvisation as a bridge to the audience, and about what artificial intelligence can do in music — and what it will never have. Hanni speaks openly about how the crash that followed her biggest success led her to the questions that actually mattered, and how that search eventually brought her to a new kind of freedom.
🎧 Listen to the full conversation on the Backstage Wisdom Podcast. 🇩🇪 This episode is in German.
Key Takeaways
The emptiness after reaching a goal isn't failure — it's where the real questions finally get space
When the dream you worked toward for years comes true, and what follows isn't fulfillment but an unexpected crash, that's often when the real search begins — for the why behind the music, for your own purpose, for a path that isn't dictated from the outside anymore.
Real connection in a concert only happens when musicians are willing to be vulnerable
Giving up control and genuinely putting yourself in the audience's hands means risking that something goes wrong — but it's exactly that risk that creates a space where the audience opens up too, sharing things they might otherwise have kept to themselves.
AI can compose, but it lacks the need to express itself
AI can process anything we feed it and generate something new from it — what it doesn't have is the lived experience of generations, or the inner drive to ask why we're doing this right now. That, arguably, is where the human part of music lives.
Deep Dive
The Emptiness After Success — And What It Uncovers
What happens the moment the goal you built your whole life around is finally achieved? Most of us never find out, because most of us never fully get there. Hanni Liang did — and what waited on the other side wasn't relief.
Her path starts almost unremarkably: no musicians in the family, piano lessons at eight because a school friend wanted to learn too. Years of études with her first teacher, then Jungstudentin status, a piano degree running parallel to a full degree in media management. Then, in her early twenties, the moment everything had built toward: her solo debut at the Elbphilharmonie, playing Liszt's First Piano Concerto. A dream, realized.
What followed surprised even her — not fulfillment, but a question that wouldn't go away: now what? She describes it not as one dramatic break but as something that built slowly, partly through encounters with people outside the classical world, including her work with the cultural project Tonali. Tellingly, she doesn't call this a shift in horizon, but a wideningof it — nothing she valued before loses its worth, more simply gets added. It's also where she pushes back on what she calls "dogma": the unspoken rule that a serious musician devotes herself exclusively to music, and that anything else puts that seriousness in question.
The emptiness after reaching a goal isn't failure — it's often the first moment the important questions finally get space.
Vulnerability as the Price of Real Connection
Out of the question why, Hanni built an entire field of work: Concert Design — the conscious questioning of every element of a concert, starting from one question: why am I on this stage, tonight, for this audience? Sometimes the answer is a concert that stays entirely traditional, and that's fine too, as long as it's a choice rather than a habit.
How far the idea can go becomes clear in a concert she gave at the Edinburgh International Festival, titled Dreams. She prepared exactly four minutes of music — Debussy's Rêverie — for a 75-minute concert. The rest was improvised live, in response to dreams the audience shared in real time on an iPad in the hall. No script, no control over what would happen. She spent six months taking weekly composition lessons to prepare, describing herself as a beginner again — able to explain Debussy's language in theory but having to relearn it in her fingers.
On the night, she says, she was completely dependent on the audience — and that uncertainty is, for her, the actual point: when an artist genuinely opens up and becomes exposed, that's what creates space for the audience to open up too. People in the hall shared things that night, some quite personal, that would never have surfaced without that mutual risk.
Real connection in a concert only happens when musicians are willing to make themselves vulnerable first.
Artificial Intelligence: A Tool, Not a Replacement
Anyone working in new concert formats runs into this topic sooner or later. Hanni approaches it with striking calm — no fear of contact, but no naive enthusiasm either. She collaborates with Ali Nikrang, a colleague at the Munich music academy who builds AI systems for composition, exploring the different roles AI can take: as tool, as co-composer, sometimes as the subject of the work itself.
What makes her view interesting is the comparison she draws: musicians never really invent something entirely new either — we process everything we've heard and played into something of our own, a melting pot of influences. At its core, not so different from how an AI works with whatever dataset it's fed.
The real difference, for her, lies elsewhere: AI doesn't carry the lived experience of generations, passed down unconsciously over time. And it has no need to express itself — no inner drive to ask why, right now, this piece and not another. That search can't be generated from data alone. Even the most capable AI still needs a human to feed it that data in the first place.
AI can compose, but it lacks the need to express itself.
Continue the Conversation
The best conversations don't end when the episode is over. They continue in the questions we ask ourselves.
1. Journal prompt: Write for 10 minutes on — "What did I feel when I reached my biggest goal so far?"
2. Practice: At your next rehearsal or show, deliberately leave one small thing to chance — and write down afterward how it felt to let go of control.
3. Reflection: What unspoken rule have you placed on yourself as a musician — and who ever actually said it was true?
Keep Exploring
Did this conversation resonate with you?
On the Backstage Wisdom Podcast, Marco Hohner speaks with musicians and experts about the realities of life behind the stage – through honest, thought-provoking conversations that go beyond easy answers.
Your Backstage Journey
Every musician's path is unique. So are the challenges that come with it.
If you're looking for greater clarity, confidence and balance – both on and off the stage – discover Marco Hohner's holistic Coaching for musicians.